[talk] Apartment plagiarism controversy completely summarized! (+ Rosé plagiarized a Japanese song?, comparison video link attached)

1. The beginning of the controversy: How did the plagiarism allegations begin?

The controversy started among international fans first. Fans started claiming that the two songs were similar, starting from the similar melodies and rhythms felt in the introduction of "APT" and "Can't Be a Good Girl" .

Especially on the first listen, there was a reaction of “it’s almost the same.” There is a lively debate among fans as to whether this is a simple coincidence or a real plagiarism.

2. Musical similarity: melody, rhythm, and instrument choice

🎵 Melody: Many people say that the opening melodies of the two songs are similar. So some fans say that it is difficult to see this as a coincidence.

🎵 Rhythm and tempo: The song's fast and repetitive rhythm is also similar, which has been the center of controversy, especially in the chorus .

🎵Instrument Selection: Many people have commented that the synthesizer and drum beats used in Rosé's song are similar to those in Miku's song, which has led to more people suspecting plagiarism.

🚨Go watch the controversial Rosé plagiarism comparison video!

3. What are some common patterns in pop music?

On the other hand, there are opinions that "APT" simply used chord progressions and melody patterns that are often used in the pop genre. In fact, since pop music often uses similar melodies and chord progressions, many argue that it is difficult to conclude that it is plagiarism.

4. Conclusion (+Between Creation and Plagiarism)

This controversy shows how vague the line between creativity and plagiarism can be in pop music.

Although there are similarities between Rosé's "APT" and Sawai Miku's "Can't Be a Good Girl," the current conclusion is that there is not enough conclusive evidence to prove that it was intentional plagiarism.

In the future, wouldn't the music industry need more guidelines to clearly distinguish between creation and inspiration? Hehe

What do you guys think about the Rosé plagiarism controversy???





Go see the latest issues!

🚨Complete summary of Hive trend report, Hive statement, reason for state audit (ft. Who are the idols mentioned?)

🚨FNC Announces Suspension of Media Activities Amid Choi Min-hwan Prostitution Controversy

🚨Park Joo-ah's personal information from the detox camp (ft. face, age, current status, assets, DC lyrics, reason for controversy, Jang Won-young)