[talk] Rise Seunghan's voluntary withdrawal, withdrawal timeline summary (ft. Rise Seunghan's motel private photos leaked? Why are Eunchae and Subin mentioned?)

A complete summary of the timeline and private life controversy surrounding Rise Seunghan's voluntary withdrawal, as well as the reason for mentioning Seraphim Eunchae and Toobatu Subin!

1. Controversy over Seunghan's private life begins 🔥
- Private photos leaked?
Last September, Seunghan debuted with Rise. However, shortly after his debut, photos from his trainee days were leaked online, sparking controversy. The photos included private moments with women and even included him smoking in Japan, which disappointed fans. After that, Seunghan eventually went on hiatus.

- Underage girlfriend motel rumor
Also, an anonymous account spread rumors mentioning provocative content such as 'visiting a motel with an underage girlfriend', but this account later deleted the account and disappeared, saying it was not true. However, from this point on, the controversy over his private life began to grow uncontrollably.

2. Announcement of return and fans' backlash 😱
- Announcement of return (October 11)
SM Entertainment announced Seunghan's return on the 11th. Fans were shocked by the news of his return, and some fans expressed strong opposition. In particular, they strongly expressed their stance by sending a wreath in front of the SM building.

- Reasons for fans' backlash
The reason why fans are so strongly opposed is because Seunghan has damaged the team's image with his private life controversy, and because he has been inactive for a long time since his debut. During that time, Rise has been steadily promoting as a 6-member group, so Seunghan's return now was difficult for fans to accept.

3. Seunghan's voluntary withdrawal announcement (October 13) 😢
- Just two days after announcing his return, Seunghan finally made the decision to leave the team. SM Entertainment respected Seunghan’s choice, saying that it was the right path for the fans and the members. Seunghan also apologized to the fans and members through a handwritten letter posted on the fan community Weverse.

4. Why were Toubatu Subin and Seraphim Eunchae mentioned? 👀
- Private live broadcast leak incident
A video of Seunghan and Subin doing a private Instagram live has been leaked and has become a hot topic among fans. In the video, Seunghan says something rude to Subin, and Subin responds by cursing at his toes, which makes everyone laugh. However, the problem is that Seunghan mentions Seraphim Eunchae during the process.

- "Our Eunchae" remark
Seunghan said to Soobin, "Let's meet Eunchae," and the word "we" here has led to various interpretations among fans. There are various interpretations as to whether Seunghan was referring to Eunchae as a fan, or whether he was hinting at the relationship between Soobin and Eunchae. In particular, Eunchae is still a minor, which has raised even more concerns among fans.

5. Fans' reactions
- After all this controversy, the fans' criticism towards Seunghan has grown stronger, and some fans think that leaving the team is the best option. As an idol and a public figure, this incident has been a huge ordeal for Rise.

Do you think it's right for Seunghan to leave?